Watching the US election can feel like a horror movie, full of scares and heart-in-mouth moments. Yet despite all the petty slogans, bitter rhetoric and big economic promises, it’s easy to overestimate the impact an election – or US president – has on portfolios.
There is no doubt, however, that the current campaign is anxiety inducing for investors. Canada may be gearing up for its own divisive political battle, but its noisy neighbour is a behemoth that dominates news cycles. And just like a good horror film, these stories are full of jumps and nerve-shredding moments. It’s only human, therefore, to get caught up in these feelings.
The assassination attempt on Donald Trump, the Joe Biden debate disaster, and the dramatic impact of his replacement, Kamala Harris, have bred uncertainty. An election by its nature is unpredictable, of course, but history tells us the equity market’s behaviour during election year often follows a pattern.
Whichever party wins, the first half of the year tends to feature muted returns followed by stronger returns later in the second half, once the outcome is known. As of August 27, the S&P 500 is up more than 19% and another bull run is well under way but that more likely reflects a growing confidence that the US Federal Reserve will cut rates, rather than excitement at Harris or Trump moving into the White House.
Despite the drama and plot twists over the years, since 1928 US equities have posted positive presidential election-year returns more than 83.3% of the time, with an average return of 11.4%1. Once the victor has been established (and especially if the Fed does cut as expected), some analysts expect things to get even better. Since 1948, stocks posted higher returns in the period after election day 63% of the time2.
To counter anxiety, it’s worth noting that while you may have a political preference, markets doesn’t play favourites, and history shows it doesn’t perform better under any one party. Stocks have performed well under both blue and red regimes – the best returns, incidentally, occurred under the F. Roosevelt, Clinton, Eisenhower and Reagan administrations.
Since 1930, the average annualized price return (excluding dividends) of the S&P 500 was 9.6% when a Democrat won and 5.7% when a Republican won. But over a longer period, results for both parties are similar, with the S&P 500 returning around 7%.3 Under Trump and Biden, despite appearing worlds apart on policy, the S&P 500 returned 14% per year under each president.
